Best Sugar Free Vanilla Syrup in 2025: Flavorful Coffee and Drink Mixes for Diabetics

📄 Disclosure
This post contains afiliate links. If you purchase through these links, i may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Discover the best sugar free vanilla syrup options for diabetics and low-carb lifestyles. Compare top brands like Torani and Jordan’s Skinny Mixes with zero sugar, zero calories, and full flavor for coffee, shakes, and more.

Sugar free vanilla syrup has become a staple in my kitchen, not just for coffee but also for smoothies and low-carb treats. I love vanilla in my coffee, but after a diabetes diagnosis I had to cut back on sugar. Sugar free vanilla syrup is a great way to sweeten coffee, cocktails or desserts, so I was thrilled to find sugar-free vanilla syrups that let me keep that cozy flavor without any actual sugar. These syrups use artificial or natural sweeteners (like sucralose, stevia or erythritol) to give you 0 calories, 0 sugar and 0 carbs. In fact, Torani proudly labels its sugar-free vanilla as “0 Calories, 0 Sugar, 0 Carbs, Keto Friendly”. In practice that means I can add a pump of syrup to my latte and still stay in range. As Skinny Mixes notes, sugar-free flavored syrups “do not raise blood sugar – they virtually do nothing to it at all”, making them a guilt-free flavor boost for diabetics.

Our Top Picks for the Best Sugar Free Vanilla Syrup

1. Best For: Coffee & Lattes — Torani Sugar Free Vanilla Syrup (25.4oz)
2. Best For: On-the-go Coffee — Torani Sugar Free Vanilla Syrup (12.7oz)
3. Best For: Neat Dispensing — Jordan’s Skinny Syrups Syrup Pump
4. Best For: Coffee & Smoothies — Jordan’s Cinnamon Vanilla (25.4oz)
5. Best For: Café-Style Drinks — Fresh Finest Brown Sugar Cinnamon (25.4oz)
6. Best For: Coffee & Shakes — Jordan’s Skinny Vanilla (2×25.4oz)
7. Best For: Dessert Coffees — Skinny Mixes Salted Caramel & Mocha (2×25.4oz)

Cutting out sugar has benefits: studies show it can aid weight loss, lower blood pressure and even support heart health. Switching from a sugar-loaded syrup to a sugar-free vanilla syrup is like getting a slimmer, heart-healthier version of your favorite flavor. It’s similar to choosing decaf or skim milk – you get nearly all the enjoyment without the unwanted effects. I find I can still indulge in vanilla cappuccinos, iced coffees or even smoothies by simply swapping in these syrups. They’re as easy as syrup, yet ideal for a diabetic diet.

Behind the scenes, most sugar-free vanilla syrups use FDA-approved sweeteners. For example, Torani’s syrup contains sucralose and acesulfame potassium, which are intensely sweet but calorie-free. Some brands like Jordan’s Skinny Mixes use stevia, erythritol and monk fruit, plant-based sweeteners that tend to have less aftertaste. (As one reviewer observed, these natural sweeteners “don’t bring as powerful of an aftertaste as artificial ones”.) I’ve noticed that syrups with stevia/monk fruit usually taste cleaner in a latte, whereas straight sucralose ones can be a touch “chemical.” Overall, I find any sugar-free syrup beats plain black coffee, and most are fat-free and keto-friendly.

Below I’m reviewing the top sugar-free vanilla syrups and accessories I’ve tried, including Torani and Jordan’s Skinny Mixes. Each section lists key features, pros and cons, and the best use case, so you can quickly pick what works for you. I’ve also included a quick comparison table and a FAQ section at the end to cover common questions. Enjoy!

Here’s a quick comparison of the top-rated sugar free vanilla syrup products we reviewed.

Whether you’re new to using sugar free vanilla syrup or a regular user, this table helps narrow down the top-rated options quickly.

Product	Price Range	Rating	Best For
Torani Sugar Free Vanilla Syrup (25.4oz)	$$ (~$15)	4.6/5	Coffee & Lattes
Torani Sugar Free Vanilla Syrup (12.7oz)	$ ($4-$6)	4.6/5	On-the-go Coffee
Jordan’s Skinny Syrups Syrup Pump	$ (~$6)	4.7/5	Neat Dispensing
Jordan’s Cinnamon Vanilla (25.4oz)	$$ (~$20)	4.4/5	Coffee & Smoothies
Fresh Finest Brown Sugar Cinnamon (25.4oz)	$$ (~$19)	4.5/5	Café-Style Drinks
Jordan’s Skinny Vanilla (2×25.4oz)	$$ (~$22)	4.6/5	Coffee & Shakes
Skinny Mixes Salted Caramel & Mocha (2×25.4oz)	$$ (~$30)	4.4/5	Dessert Coffees

1. Torani Sugar Free Coffee Syrup, Vanilla (25.4 fl oz)

Choosing the right sugar free vanilla syrup depends on your taste preferences, dietary goals, and how you plan to use it—whether it’s coffee, baking, or smoothies.

This sugar free vanilla syrup blends well in cold brew or hot coffee. Torani is a trusted coffeehouse brand, and its sugar-free vanilla syrup is a go-to for many. I like that it comes in a large 750 ml pump bottle – one bottle lasts a long time. It smells richly of vanilla bean, and in taste tests it adds a true vanilla sweetness to drinks. Torani’s version is fat-free, keto-friendly and gluten-free, and labels say 0 Sugar, 0 Calories, 0 Carbs. In practice I find it blends effortlessly into coffee or tea. However, it’s sweetened with artificial sweeteners (sucralose and acesulfame), so the sweetness can come off a bit “sharp” on its own. In my experience it’s smoother when mixed with coffee or milk.

• Key features:
  • Zero calories
  • Pump included
  • 750 ml bottle
  • Keto-friendly
  • Authentic vanilla flavor
• Pros:
  • Rich vanilla taste
  • Large supply (25.4 oz)
  • Versatile in drinks
  • Quality brand reputation
• Cons:
  • Artificial sweetener aftertaste
  • Relatively bulky/pumps can wear out
  • Higher price per bottle
• Best for: Coffee flavoring

This sugar free vanilla syrup blends well in cold brew or hot coffee.

This syrup works great if you want a coffeehouse-style vanilla latte at home. For convenience, check the current price on Amazon.

2. Torani Sugar Free Syrup, Vanilla (12.7 Ounce)

Choosing the right sugar free vanilla syrup depends on your taste preferences, dietary goals, and how you plan to use it—whether it’s coffee, baking, or smoothies.

This sugar free vanilla syrup blends well in cold brew or hot coffee. If the big Torani bottle is too much for you, this smaller 12.7 oz version has the same formulation in a handy size. I keep one on my desk at work. It still delivers that pure vanilla aroma and mixes well in hot or cold drinks. Like the larger bottle, it has 0 sugar and 0 calories. It’s also labeled Gluten-Free, Keto-Friendly, and Kosher. The smaller size is less storage space and a bit easier to finish before it expires. On the downside, it doesn’t include a pump – you’ll pour it straight or squeeze (which can get messy). The flavor is identical to the larger bottle, so watch out for the same slightly sharp sweetener note.

• Key features:
  • Zero sugar/calories
  • 12.7 oz bottle
  • Fat-free
  • Gluten-free, Kosher
  • Handy travel size
• Pros:
  • Same rich flavor as 25.4 oz
  • Compact for travel/office
  • Affordable small size
• Cons:
  • No pump (cap can drip)
  • Empties quickly with frequent use
  • Contains sucralose (some find it sharp)
• Best for: On-the-go coffee

I often stash this Torani bottle in my bag so I can sweeten coffee at work or on trips. (Affiliate Link)

3. Jordan’s Skinny Mixes Syrup Pump (fits 750ml bottles)

This sugar free vanilla syrup blends well in cold brew or hot coffee. This isn’t a flavor syrup, but a syrup pump dispenser that fits standard 750 ml bottles (like the Torani and Skinny Mixes syrups). Installing one has been a game-changer. The pump dispenses a consistent ¼ ounce per push, so I get the exact amount of syrup every time. Its fixed tip design prevents drips and mess – no more sticky counter or lid. It’s made of sturdy, BPA-free plastic and screws on easily in place of the original cap.

• Key features:
  • Fits 750 ml syrup bottles
  • Drip-free tip design
  • Delivers ~7 ml (¼ oz) per pump
  • Easy twist-on attachment
• Pros:
  • Clean, mess-free pouring
  • Accurate portion control
  • Durable plastic build
  • Enhances any coffee bar setup
• Cons:
  • Plastic pump (not glass)
  • Sold individually (need one per bottle)
  • May not fit very small bottles
• Best for: Syrup dispensing

Adding this pump to my syrup bottles makes daily use so much neater. It even says “no more mess” right on the label. I use it with all my syrup bottles now.

4. Jordan’s Skinny Syrups, Cinnamon Vanilla (25.4 Ounce)

This sugar free vanilla syrup blends well in cold brew or hot coffee. This flavor adds a cozy twist to plain vanilla with a swirl of cinnamon. I like it in fall-flavored drinks or even plain coffee when I want a little spice. It’s sugar-free with 0 calories – labeled “0 sugar, 0 calorie, and 0 carbs” for guilt-free sipping. Like other Skinny Mixes, it’s gluten-free, kosher, non-GMO and keto-friendly. The cinnamon note comes through nicely, but vanilla is more of a gentle background here. A little goes a long way (the label suggests just 2 tbsp per drink). It mixes well in both hot and cold drinks.

• Key features:
  • Cinnamon vanilla flavor
  • 25.4 oz bottle
  • Zero sugar/carbs/calories
  • Gluten-free, kosher, keto-friendly
  • Made in USA
• Pros:
  • Warming, spiced aroma
  • Rich and sweet without sugar
  • Great in coffee, yogurt, baking
  • Large 750 ml bottle
• Cons:
  • Can be thin consistency
  • Must use enough pumps for strong flavor
  • Cinnamon may overpower vanilla for some
• Best for: Spiced coffee drinks

I’ve used this syrup in iced lattes and even oatmeal for a cinnamon-vanilla kick. It pairs well with cold foam or whipped cream.

5. Fresh Finest Sugar Free Brown Sugar Cinnamon (25.4 Ounces, with Pump)

This sugar free vanilla syrup blends well in cold brew or hot coffee. This is a bold take on sweetness – brown sugar and cinnamon. It smells like a warm spice cookie. I actually use this as an alternative to vanilla when I want a deeper, richer flavor in coffee or tea. It’s sugar-free (again, 0 sugar, 0 calories, 0 carbs), and the bottle comes with a pump. According to the maker, the brown sugar cinnamon “elevates a simple drink to divine goodness”. The pump dispenses about 8 ml (¼ oz) per press, so it works perfectly for portion control. This syrup is fairly thick and coats drinks nicely. I do find it a bit pricey per ounce compared to plain vanilla, but the flavor is unique.

• Key features:
  • Brown sugar & cinnamon flavor
  • 25.4 oz bottle with pump included
  • 8 ml (¼ oz) per pump
  • Sugar-free (0 cal/carbs)
  • BPA-free pump (dispenses cleanly)
• Pros:
  • Rich café-style flavor
  • Includes dispenser pump
  • Large supply for multiple drinks
  • Versatile (great in coffee, desserts)
• Cons:
  • Higher price per oz ($0.71/fl oz)
  • Taste may seem artificial (sweetener aftertaste)
  • Very sweet (only a little needed)
• Best for: Café-style drinks

I love using this in my cold brew or even on pancakes. It really does taste like a touch of brown sugar without the calories.

6. Jordan’s Skinny Syrups, Vanilla (25.4 fl oz, 2-Pack)

This sugar free vanilla syrup blends well in cold brew or hot coffee. This is the classic vanilla from Jordan’s Skinny, now in a 2-bottle bundle. Buying two bottles at once is great value – I keep one at home and one at work. The formula is the same zero-sugar, zero-calorie vanilla flavor. I’ve found it mixes very smoothly and tastes very close to a regular vanilla syrup. It uses high-quality vanilla flavoring, so it doesn’t taste as “sharp” as some cheaper syrups. Both bottles are labeled keto and diabetic friendly. I do have to mention that compared to some premium syrups, this one is a bit thinner, so I sometimes use an extra pump.

• Key features:
  • Two 25.4 oz bottles (vanilla)
  • 0 sugar, 0 calories
  • Gluten-free, kosher, non-GMO
  • Made in the USA
• Pros:
  • Great vanilla taste
  • Cost-effective 2-pack
  • Perfect for sharing or stock-up
  • Versatile (coffee, protein shakes, baking)
• Cons:
  • Flavor is mild (may need extra pumps)
  • Slight syrupy consistency (not thick)
  • Contains artificial sweeteners (some may prefer plant-based)
• Best for: Coffee & shakes

I often use this for everything from vanilla chai to smoothie sweetening. Having an extra bottle on hand means I never run out of vanilla flavor.

7. Jordan’s Skinny Mixes Sugar Free Syrups, Salted Caramel & Mocha (2-Pack, 25.4 fl oz each)

This sugar free vanilla syrup blends well in cold brew or hot coffee. This two-pack gives you Salted Caramel and Mocha flavors, both sugar-free and keto-friendly. As a vanilla fan, I appreciate having variety – salted caramel is great in iced coffees, and mocha is like dessert in a cup. Each bottle is 25.4 oz and boasts “0 calories, 0 sugar, 0 carbs”. According to the product description, the salted caramel has “smooth caramel and salt accents” while the mocha has “rich chocolate flavor”. I found that these syrups deliver on that – they really taste like candy-drink flavors. The mocha is especially good with any chocolate protein shake. Both are certified gluten-free and made in the USA. You do pay for two bottles, but it’s handy for mixing up different drinks.

• Key features:
  • Salted Caramel flavor (25.4 oz)
  • Mocha flavor (25.4 oz)
  • Zero sugar, zero calories
  • Gluten-free, non-GMO, kosher
  • 25 servings total (50 pumps)
• Pros:
  • Decadent dessert-style flavors
  • Twin pack for variety
  • Promises “0 Calories, 0 Sugar, 0 Carbs”
  • Made in USA quality
• Cons:
  • Pricey bundle
  • Mocha can overpower subtle drinks
  • Syrups are fairly thin in texture
• Best for: Sweet coffee treats

I found these perfect when I want a latte that feels like a bakery treat. A splash of the mocha syrup in a cappuccino is amazing.

FAQ

Choosing the best sugar free vanilla syrup depends on taste, ingredients, and how you like your coffee.

• What is a sugar free vanilla syrup and how is it different from traditional syrup?? Sugar-free vanilla syrup is a vanilla-flavored sweetener that uses no sugar. Instead, it uses artificial or natural low-calorie sweeteners (sucralose, stevia, erythritol, etc.) to mimic the sweetness of sugar. It adds vanilla flavor to drinks without the carbs and calories of regular syrup.
• How many calories are in sugar-free vanilla syrup? Almost none. These syrups are formulated to be zero-calorie. Most brands (like Torani and Skinny Mixes) list 0 calories, 0 sugar and 0 carbs per serving. This lets you sweeten coffee or tea without adding any real calories.
• Are sugar-free vanilla syrups safe for diabetics? Yes. Since they contain no real sugar and do not raise blood glucose levels, they are considered diabetic-friendly. The American Diabetes Association notes that zero-calorie sweeteners won’t spike blood sugar, although they recommend using them in moderation. For me, switching to sugar-free syrup means I can still enjoy sweet drinks without guilt or health impact.
• Can I use sugar-free vanilla syrup in recipes? Absolutely. These syrups dissolve in hot or cold liquids, so you can use them in coffee, tea, protein shakes, smoothies or even baking. Some readers use them in pancake or waffle batter, oatmeal, yogurt, or cocktails for flavor. (Just remember they are flavorings, not bulking sugars, so they add taste, not structure. It works great when a recipe calls for “vanilla syrup” flavor.)
• What’s the best sugar-free vanilla syrup brand? Many people love Torani and Jordan’s Skinny Mixes for their consistent vanilla taste. According to reviews, Torani’s sugar-free vanilla is very well-known, and Jordan’s Skinny Mixes often scores high in taste. It depends on whether you prefer a pump and a big size (Torani) or multiple flavors and bundles (Jordan’s). Both deliver genuine vanilla flavor and a true sugar-free experience.

Whether you’re new to diabetes management or just looking to cut sugar, switching to sugar free vanilla syrup is one of the easiest changes you can make.

Sources: I used product information and reviews to compile these recommendations. For example, Torani’s label shows “0 Calories, 0 Sugar, 0 Carbs”, and testing sites note that sugar-free vanilla syrups “do not raise blood sugar”. The CDC reports about 38.4 million Americans have diabetes, highlighting why these sugar-free options can be so important.